Request: Can you do a Seth Rollins one where he and Reader have their first time together and he’s just super nervous because he doesn’t want to hurt her and just super fluffy and smutty?
After lying to her parents that she was sleeping at Amanda’s house, Y/N managed to sneak away to spend the weekend at Seth’s. His parents would be out of town and trusted him enough to leave him alone. To her surprise, instead of throwing a big party, he decided instead to invite her over. They had been dating for a little over a year and the chemistry between them could be seen by anyone around, but they wanted their first time to be perfect so they had waited for the right moment.
That moment was tonight. The circumstances were perfect. They loved each other. They had the place to themselves all weekend. They could take their time and make it really special.
Still, the nerves were setting in.
She looked at herself in the bathroom mirror, adjusting her new purchased Victoria’s Secret bra and panties. After brushing her teeth, she fluffed her hair a little trying to look as sexy as possible.
With one more deep breath in the mirror she stepped out of his bathroom, making her way into his bedroom only to be caught off-guard when she opened the door.
“Seth!” She exclaimed in awh as she looked at the candlelit room.
He’d sprinkled rose petals all over the place and placed candles all over to give the room a more romantic feel.
“You like -” He started to say before he turned around to fully see her. “Woah.. Y/N.. you look…”
“You like?” She blushed, doing a small twirl for him.
“I love.” He replied, sitting back on his bed. “Come here.”
She nodded, crossing the room to stand between his legs. He’d had her in his room millions of times but this time was different. This time it was going to lead to something else.
He placed a hand on her cheek, pulling her head down to his lips, kissing her softly.
“Are you – uh .. ready?” He asked, unsure of how to even start this.
“I .. I am.” She replied.
He nodded, lifting her by her waist to turn them around so she was on her back on the bed with him on top of her. Leaning down to kiss her again the two started to make out slowly at first then with more passion. She reached down his body, pulling his shirt over his head while he grinded his hardening dick in between her legs, reaching back to try and unclip her bra.
“Grr, fuck.” He groaned, breaking the kiss to try undoing her bra with both hands. “What are these things made of?!”
She laughed, “Here, let me help.” She said reaching back to unclip her bra, sliding it off her body.
“Holy shit…” He said, his jaw dropping. “Those… those are…”
“Shut up.” She laughed, hiding her blush by pulling his head back down to kiss again. He kissed her again working his hands down to her breasts, massaging them as they pressed against his chest.
Slowly he worked his jeans off, leaving the two of them in just boxers and underwear. They knew what the next step was but they hadn’t gotten there yet.
She made her way to kiss down his neck, her legs wrapped around his waist while he continued to grind against her center. He ran his hands down her body, grabbing the sides of her panties to pull them down her long legs and bit his lip as he took in the view.
He was in awh again but if he said wow one more time he swore she’d think he was a weirdo. Inside he groaned, pushing his boxers down his legs.
“Woah.” She said, her eyes wide as she looked down to see him.
From that he got a small boost of confidence, stroking his dick before reaching to grab a condom from his nightstand. Tearing the wrapper, he did his best to look cool trying to figure out the best way to put it on.
“Do you need help?” Y/N asked, watching him fumble.
“No.” He replied, before letting out a high pitched yell when the condom snapped on him. “Ow fuck!”
She did her best to hold back a laugh, sitting up to reach for another, reading the directions. “Okay, so you squeeze the tip.”
“Of my dick?” He interrupted.
“No babe.” She laughed, “of the condom. Then you roll it onto the length.”
He did as she said rolling it up without an issue this time.
“What would you do without me?” She smiled, biting her lip as she watched.
“Shut up.” He smiled, pushing her gently on her back again and pulling her closer.
Sliding himself back and forth between her folds like he’d seen online, they both took a deep breath, with Seth leaning up on his elbow to take a look at her face.
“Are you ready baby?”
“I’m ready, babe.” Y/N nodded.
He leaned down to kiss her one more time before slowly starting to push himself in. The feeling for him was intense but he could see from her face that she was in pain and pulled out immediately.
“What?” She asked confused, “What’s wrong?”
“I – you – It looks like it hurts.”
Biting her lip, she nodded. “A little, but I read it’s supposed to..”
“I don’t wanna do it if it hurts you.” He brushed her hair back from her face.
“I want this.” She nodded reassuringly.
He nodded, looking down to concentrate again as he lined himself up. Closing his eyes, he groaned pushing himself in little further and when he felt stuck, he thrusted a little more just like he’d read about online. He felt something he couldn’t describe and suddenly she moaned out and he was able to slide all the way in.
Was that the hymen? Yup.
He groaned at how tight she was squeeze around him and he stopped, letting them both adjust to this new depth. She squeezed his shoulders as she took a few deep breaths, meeting his eyes.
“Was that the thing…?”
“I think so.” He confirmed, “Should I keep going? Are you okay?”
“Yeah – yes.” She nodded.
Seth smiled down at her, lifting one of her legs higher over his hip as he began to thrust, slowly at first before the feeling overcame him and he started moving faster.
There was nothing like the sounds of her moans in his ear and the feel of her wrapped around him.
“Seth” She moaned, running her nails down her back as she threw her head back. “Oh my god!”
“Holy shit!” He groaned, increasing his movements as she tightened around him and suddenly he came.
“Wow.” She breathed as he rolled off of her catching her breath. “That was incredible.”
“Yeah it was.” He nodded, breathing heavily as he looked up at the ceiling.
“I love you so much Seth.” Y/N smiled, looking over at him.
“I love you babe.”
*Gif’s not mine!
Please excuse any typos, I’ve really been avoiding proofreading :/
I hope you enjoyed! As always – let me know if you have any requests. 🙂